Not Guilty by Reason of Insanity

Akshay Chand has been acquitted of the murder of Christie Marceau, on the grounds of insanity.

Akshay Chand today has been acquitted of the murder of Christie Marceau, on the grounds of insanity. Click here for the full story.

Quoted from the article: “Chand hatched a plan to get out of jail. He wrote a letter to the court expressing his remorse, saying he was not a safety risk, and he got bail to his mother’s house in Hillcrest.” This plan worked, and could easily look like premeditated murder. What do you think?

The defense of insanity has been called “probably the most controversial issue in all of criminal law” (Melton et. al, 1987). The term insanity is actually a legal term that isn’t used in psychological literature. According to Black’s Law Dictionary (Garner, 1996) it is defined as; “Any mental disorder severe enough that it prevents one from having legal capacity and excuses one from criminal or civil responsibility”

So, insanity is a legal standard – not a medical or psychological standard.  Based on this theory, the presence of insanity doesn’t allow for an individual to form “criminal intent” – therefore they lack “blame worthiness”. The legal is meant to look at it as simply as rehabilitation versus punishment. In order for there to be criminal liability there needs to be the combination of criminal intent (mens rea) and a wrongful act (actus reus) present.

In the US, the insanity defense is employed around 1 out of every 200 criminal cases, with only around 1% being successful. Not guilty by reason of insanity is also different than guilty but mentally ill. Usually, people found insane are treated in more of a hospital setting than a prison – and could remain there for (in some instances) longer than they would have had they been convicted normally. People found guilty but mentally ill are treated until they are competent to stand trial to then be convicted.

Whether it was premeditated murder or insanity – I think the signs were there and the murder of Christie Marceau should have been prevented.


About Stu Dunn

I have three major professional areas in my life: Team Dunn Real Estate (Harcourts Real Estate with my beautiful wife Bridget), SDL (Behavioural Science Consulting) and Qian Li Dao Academy NZ (Wing Chun Kung Fu). Stu & Bridget Dunn Real Estate: Providing awesome service and results through our approachable, professional and effective real estate services. SDL: SDL helps our clients to understand non-verbal communication and to avoid deception. We do this by providing online courses, training and specialist advice in areas of behaviour, emotional analysis and detecting deception. Both my wife Bridget and I are also FACS certified. I have also written an International Best Seller, True Lies; A Guide To Reading Faces, Interpreting Body Language & Detecting Deception In The Real World., & Qian Li Dao Academy NZ (Wing Chun Kung Fu): The Wing Chun System, known for its incredible speed, powerful straight punches & Chi Sao (contact reflex training), relies on angling & body mechanics rather than brute force.
This entry was posted in Psychology and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s