Genuine Emotions on Screen

Some actors are more expressive than others… Click to enlarge

As an unfortunate side effect of years of examining facial expressions I’ve become quite critical of what I can only describe as poor acting. As much as I love Criminal Minds, it ruins it for me to see someone being attacked who is not actually showing fear, a touching moment during a movie where the actor merely frowns rather than expresses sadness – and in particular – where an actor attempts to demonstrate real loss / grief / despair.

Genuine sadness is most often identified with the raising of the inner eyebrow (AU1) and lowering the brows (AU4), creating an arch-shaped eyebrow /   \.  As this eyebrow movement can be challenging to imitate / mimic, it’s regularly missing from an actor’s repertoire. In saying that, convincing happiness is also alarmingly absent in many television programs – and regularly in high budget movies. Surely it would be worth their while hiring an emotional / FACS specialist to scan the material before things are immortalised on screen..?

Tobey Maguire frowning to demonstrate sadness

Genuine sadness and overwhelming joy can look very similar

With this in mind, television programs such as Lie To Me appeared to force actors to physically express the most correct and genuine expressions they could. And then there’s Dexter. As a Dexter fan, I’ve been really impressed with Jennifer Carpenter’s acting – who plays the character “Debra Morgan”. One clip in particular I thought to myself comes across as such genuine agony and grief – coming from an actor who truly throws herself right into the role. In my opinion, actors like this are few and far between, and fall into the category of a great actor – actors such as Al Pacino, Jack Nicholson, Robert De Niro, Sean Connery, Meryl Streep & Natalie Portman.


About Stu Dunn

With a background in sales and behavioural science, I enjoy learning more about people, behaviour, psychology - which led into motivation - and more recently - sales again. Having started my own real estate company with my wife, it's time to merge interests.
This entry was posted in Emotions, Facial Expressions and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Genuine Emotions on Screen

  1. SDL says:

    I must add Claire Danes (who plays Carrie Mathison on Homeland) to this list

  2. Pingback: Robbie Parker Statement “Off” | The Blog for Stu Dunn

Comments are closed.